Automated
Blow-Down Cost Justification
What is the most
common "objective" to
the purchase of an automatic
boiler blow down system?
Right, it costs too much!
Here's a suggestion to help
overcome that objection. Analyze
the operation and come up with a
payback figure.
Take the following example:
A process boiler producing
100,000 pounds per hour of
steam. The operator has been
told to maintain chlorides at
18 - 22 ppm. His records show
that he averages 20 ppm, which
is pretty good for manual blow down.
However, automatic
blow down could bring the average up to
21 ppm without exceeding 22.
This would reduce the blow down
by 5%. (21 - 20) / 20 = .05 or
5%.
Typically, 20 ppm results
from 10 cycles of
concentration. The blow down required to maintain 10 cycles
is 10,000 lbs/hr (100,000 / 10
= 10,000).
If the 10,000 lbs/hr is
reduced by 5%, that's a
savings of 500 lbs/hr. 500
lbs/hr at 400 BTU/lb is
200,000 BTU/hr. A gallon of
oil is about 100,000 BTU, so
the oil consumption will
reduce by 2 gallons/hr. At a
dollar a gallon, that's $2
every hour!
If an automatic
blow down system costs $1300, it will
take 650 hours, or 27 days, to
pay for the system!!! ($1300 /
2 = 650) (650 / 24 = 27).
This was all based on zero
condensate return. If there is
50% return, the payback period
doubles in 54 days. That's
still a short pay-back
period.
Of course, the savings
continue after the pay-back
period.
|